A World Without Sherlock Holmes? - We Owe A Great Debt to Bertram Fletcher Robinson

Posted by Steve Emecz on

Devon author and Holmes investigator, Paul R Spiring has proved that if it were not for Conan Doyle's close friend, Bertram Fletcher Robinson, we would not have the Sherlock Holmes character we know and love today.

In local newspaper articles from the Herald Express and Western Morning News and in a BBC Wales radio interview Paul revealed how he came across the letters that prove that Arthur Conan Doyle had more than a little help with the key story that launched Holmes worldwide.

Winding the clock back to the early 20th century and Arthur Conan Doyle had killed Holmes off and while the character had achieved some limited success, this was largely restricted to the UK. A lifelong friend of Conan Doyle's was a young man, himself an accomplished writer, called Bertram Fletcher Robinson.

Not much was known about Robinson, other than that he had died tragically young, before the acclaimed biography called simply 'Betram Fletcher Robinson - A Footnote To The Hound Of The Baskervilles' written and compiled by Spiring and Brian W Pugh was published in 2008.

In the biography Spiring and Pugh talk about the great friendship between Robinson and Conan Doyle and how they had 'collaborated' on 'The Hound' and that Robinson was often referred to as the 'assistant plot producer' for the book. The biography talks about a very talented writer who also collaborated with such big names as PG Wodehouse - you can read their main works in the book 'Bobbles and Plum', but it was his friendship with Conan Doyle that is of the greatest interest.

Without a doubt if it wasn't for 'The Hound' there would be no Sherlock Holmes today. No movies, no BBC TV series, no legions of fans around the world. It was the story that turned Holmes into the worldwide phenomenon that has led to millions of fans, many films, hundreds of books and and ongoing legacy for Conan Doyle.

So what has Spiring uncovered? Quite simply the written proof that Conan Doyle paid his friend the modern day equivalent of £45,000 [£500 at the time] for his help on the story. Conan Doyle was due to receive an estimated £1/2m in modern day values for the story so the payment to Robinson was about 10% of what Conan Doyle was to get. This proves, beyond reasonable doubt, that Robinson made a significant contribution to the storyline.

It is well documented that Conan Doyle lent on friends and particularly family for ideas and indeed characters for his storylines but for him to go as far as handing over such a huge sum of money for the input is significant. What a shame it is that Robinson was taken from us at such a young age, dying shortly after from poisoning [in his biography Spring and Pugh go into the accusations that Conan Doyle was the one that poisoned him].

He was a very talented writer of similar storylines to Conan Doyle as well as the playlets he wrote with Wodehouse. You can read twenty of his stories in 'Aside Arthur Conan Doyle' which was also compiled by Spiring.

So in summary, all Holmes fans need to give a big thanks to Bertram Fletcher Robinson, without whom they would not have their wonderful character - and personally a big thank-you to Paul Spiring for proving it once and for all. 

Share this post

← Older Post Newer Post →