Sherlock Book Reviews - The Incredible Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
Posted by Steve Emecz on
5/5 stars - Reedsy
"The four-story collection provides a cohesion that raises The Incredible Adventures of Sherlock Holmes beyond a simple anthology."
Amanda Knight’s dynamic, four-story collection is one of the most intense reads in the current steady trickle of MX Publishing's Holmes adventures. Knight excavates the late Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s literary universe and pulls Sherlock Holmes into tales that test the limits of his intellect, his body, and his heart. Overall, the work begs the argument that the world’s most famously self‑contained, consulting detective is not only capable of emotional depth, but that his humanity is the missing piece in the Holmesian canon.
That is clearly shown in the book’s gravitational center - a bruising novella, “Sherlock Holmes Meets: Atropos.” The novella begins in familiar territory - foggy London, a shadowed pursuit in full deductive flight, but Knight wastes no time wrenching the hero into a darker, more intimate narrative that treads into physical trials and beyond Holmes' traditional love interest, Irene Adler.
Sherlock is abducted, beaten, and imprisoned in a stone cell alongside Charlotte Grahame, a young woman whose presence becomes the emotional axis of the story. Their relationship—tentative, intelligent, and quietly transformative—gives the story its pulse.
There is a yin-yang balance in the author's use of Rebecca Moriarty, widow of Holmes' nemesis. The struggle to balance good and evil knocks the hero into a free fall. The best part about "Atropos" is Knight's willingness to let Holmes break. Readers will see his defenses slowly wear, and marvel at how Charlotte’s steadiness becomes a lifeline. Captivity strips him down to something at which Doyle's tales only hint - a man terrified of needing anyone.
Knight's stylish prose respects Doyle’s diction and pacing, but she expands the protagonist's emotional register. As a result, Holmes almost seems from our era than the Victorian. He displays moral ambiguity, rage, missteps, even lethal force, which deepens the novella's thematic reach to show justice, consequence, and the cost of survival. In short, Knight reinterprets the original to imagine what Doyle did not — a Holmes who feels, suffers, and survives not through intellect alone, but through the fragile, necessary connections he spends his life trying to avoid.
In comparison, the other stories, “Holmes’ Run,” “No Rats Need Apply,” and “The Singular Case of the Farquhar Ruby,” are akin to palate cleansers. They are light, puzzle‑driven, and structurally tighter, with the classic Holmes wit. They provide a cohesion that raises The Incredible Adventures of Sherlock Holmes beyond a simple anthology.
The Incredible Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is available from this site with a meal going to someone in need through ShareTheMeal, and also avilable from:
Amazon USA Barnes and Noble Kindle
About The Book
Sherlock Holmes returns in five new investigations that bridge the gap between the grim and the absurd. A struggle against the hangman’s noose, a vanished victim, and a descent into the whimsical "oddness" of the criminal mind await.
In this collection of short stories, the line between desperate tragedy and bizarre fate is thinner than ever.
Sherlock Holmes meets Atropos
Holmes is making his way home in a sudden fog. He doesn’t make it. A story of revenge, regret, loss and ultimate struggle for sanity.
Holmes Run
Holmes is accused of murder, he must find who the real culprits are before his is tracked down and sentence to hang. Even Watson has been persuaded of his guilt.
No Rats Need Apply
Holmes and Watson come face to face with the legendary Giant Rat of Sumatra in their own town of London. An adventure of explosions and danger. Will anyone believe them?
Sherlock’s Wet Wednesday
On a miserable and damp evening, Holmes is bored and restless and Watson would rather be left to read his paper. Holmes relates one of his more unusual tales from a time before his Boswell had joined him.
The Singular Case of The Farquhar Ruby
A precious stone is stolen from the museum, twice. It is up to Holmes to find out what has really happened.